Your cart is currently empty.
Enable cookies to use the shopping cart
Taxes and shipping calculated at checkout
Be sure to read our shipping and delivery info before checking out
Build your own variety box of DeWitt's!
Our signature cookie! This American classic is packed with rich Belgian chocolate that's sure to excite your taste buds!
Creamy peanut butter, plus peanut butter chips, equals a peanut butter explosion!
Our signature chocolate chip cookie, with a cocoa infusion! For chocolate lovers only... CHOCOLATE LOVERS ONLY!!!
Real oats, sweet raisins, grandma taste!
Choose one of two delicious flavors to celebrate your joyous occasion! Add custom text to make it your own! *24h...
Premium vanilla bean ice cream (from Cool Creations in Lockport) nestled between two chocolate chip DeWitt's! It's ic...
Our spin on an old classic.. The coconut & almond makes them good, but it's the hint of lemon that takes this old...